Saturday, November 25, 2017
tbt*

Kelly’s Civil War remarks: ‘Strange,’ ‘sad,’ and ‘wrong’

RECOMMENDED READING


White House Chief of Staff John Kelly was the guest for the premiere of Laura Ingraham’s show on Fox News Monday night. During the interview, he outlined a view of the history of the Civil War that historians described as "strange," "highly provocative," "dangerous" and "kind of depressing."

Kelly was asked about the decision of a church in Alexandria, Va., to remove plaques honoring George Washington and Robert E. Lee. "I would tell you that Robert E. Lee was an honorable man," Kelly said. "He was a man that gave up his country to fight for his state, which 150 years ago was more important than country. It was always loyalty to state first back in those days. Now it’s different today. But the lack of an ability to compromise led to the Civil War, and men and women of good faith on both sides made their stand where their conscience had them make their stand."

"That statement could have been given by (former Confederate general) Jubal Early in 1880," said Stephanie McCurry, professor of history at Columbia University and author of Confederate Reckoning: Politics and Power in the Civil War South.

"What’s so strange about this statement is how closely it tracks or resembles the view of the Civil War that the South had finally got the nation to embrace by the early 20th century," she said. "It’s the Jim Crow version of the causes of the Civil War .?.?. it tracks all of the major talking points of this pro-Confederate view of the Civil War."

Kelly makes several points. That Lee was honorable. That a lack of compromise led to the war. That good people on both sides were fighting for conscientious reasons. Both McCurry and David Blight, professor of history at Yale University and author of Race and Reunion: The Civil War in American Memory, broadly reject all of these arguments.

"This is profound ignorance, that’s what one has to say first, at least of pretty basic things about the American historical narrative," Blight said. "I mean, it’s one thing to hear it from Trump who, let’s be honest, just really doesn’t know any history and has demonstrated it over and over and over. But Gen. Kelly has a long history in the American military."

Blight described Kelly’s argument in similar terms as McCurry — an "old reconciliationist narrative" about the Civil War that, in the last half-century or so has "just been exploded" by historical research since.

The idea that compromise might have been possible was rejected out of hand by both McCurry and Blight.

"It was not about slavery, it was about honorable men fighting for honorable causes?" McCurry said. "Well, what was the cause? .?.?. In 1861, they were very clear on what the causes of the war were. The reason there was no compromise possible was that people in the country could not agree over the wisdom of the continued and expanding enslavement of millions of African-Americans."

There were a number of compromises on slavery that led up to the Civil War, from the drafting of the Constitution to the addition of new states to the Union.

"Any serious person who knows anything about this," Blight said, "can look at the late 1850s and then the secession crisis and know that they tried all kind of compromise measures during the secession winter, and nothing worked. Nothing was viable."

"All of these compromises were about creating a division where slavery already existed and where for a time they conceded that the Constitution shackled them in their ability to attack it," McCurry said. Before the war, the strategy for dealing with slavery was to contain it. By 1860, she said, the North’s economic success and expanding population and the South’s loss of representation in national politics put slavery at risk. The election of Abraham Lincoln in 1860 allowed Southern slaveholders — who had $4 billion in wealth in the form of enslaved people, McCurry said — to argue that the threat to slavery was imminent.

"In 1861, compromise wasn’t possible because some Southerners just wanted out. They wanted a separate nation where they could protect slavery into the indefinite future," McCurry said. "That’s what they said when they seceded. That’s what they said in their constitution when they wrote one."

"Of course we yearn for compromise, we yearn for civility, we yearn for some common ground," Blight said. "But, look, Robert E. Lee was not a compromiser. He chose treason."

"The best of the Lee biographies show that Lee was a Confederate nationalist," Blight said. "He knew what he was fighting for."

Washington Post

Comments
Local craft beer of the week: Mischievous Black Lager

Local craft beer of the week: Mischievous Black Lager

Florida’s big year at the Great American Beer Festival, with seven Sunshine State brews medaling in the largest competition in the U.S., nearly double the second-best year of 2014, which saw four medals, one from the pro-am competition.Even more rema...
Published: 11/23/17
7 local gift ideas for the geek in your life

7 local gift ideas for the geek in your life

Published: 11/23/17
Holiday brews: 6 merry pours, and a Scrooge

Holiday brews: 6 merry pours, and a Scrooge

Winter beers are always worth looking forward to, since there’s nothing nicer during the holidays than drinking a festive spiced beer with friends and family. The ever-changing selection of beers brewed for the season means that you’ll always have so...
Published: 11/22/17
Local craft beer of the week: Pep in Yo Step Double IPA, Infusion Brewing Co.

Local craft beer of the week: Pep in Yo Step Double IPA, Infusion Brewing Co.

Pepper beers walk a fine line. The best ones, as is the case with most spicy endeavors, are as much about flavor as they are heat.Some, like Twisted Pine’s Ghost Face Killah, exist almost solely to push the boundaries of what one person can consume (...
Published: 11/16/17
Local craft beer of the week: Brett Singel Aged on Plums, Crooked Thumb Brewing

Local craft beer of the week: Brett Singel Aged on Plums, Crooked Thumb Brewing

It’s been nearly a year since the first bottle release from Safety Harbor’s Crooked Thumb Brewing. Two brews were released at that event, both from the brewery’s Abbey of the South series, a line of brews inspired by the iconic styles traditionally b...
Updated one month ago
She flipped off Trump — and got fired from her government contracting job

She flipped off Trump — and got fired from her government contracting job

It was the middle-finger salute seen around the world.Juli Briskman’s protest aimed at the presidential motorcade that roared past her while she was on her usual cycling ride in Northern Virginia last month became an instantly viral photo.Turns out i...
Updated one month ago

David Lennon: Astros-Dodgers provided epic Series, until Game 7

BC-BBO-LENNON-COLUMN-1ST-LEDE:ND - sports (700 words),0755David Lennon: Astros-Dodgers provided epic Series, until Game 7(EDITORS: This story may not be used on websites) (PHOTOS)By David LennonNewsday (TNS)LOS ANGELES - The Dodgers tapped franchise ...
Updated one month ago
Local craft beer of the week: Cherry Blonde ale, St. Pete Brewing

Local craft beer of the week: Cherry Blonde ale, St. Pete Brewing

One of the major benefits of visiting your local brewery is the ability to try one-off batches, often versions of flagship offerings with various flavoring additions.Some of these beers eventually make it to the production level, like Cigar City’s Wh...
Updated one month ago
Kelly’s Civil War remarks: ‘Strange,’ ‘sad,’ and ‘wrong’

Kelly’s Civil War remarks: ‘Strange,’ ‘sad,’ and ‘wrong’

White House Chief of Staff John Kelly was the guest for the premiere of Laura Ingraham’s show on Fox News Monday night. During the interview, he outlined a view of the history of the Civil War that historians described as "strange," "highly provocati...
Updated one month ago
Mueller strikes as a small player flips on, well, we’ll see

Mueller strikes as a small player flips on, well, we’ll see

Although the biggest news Monday were the indictments Robert Mueller handed down against former President Donald Trump aides Paul Manafort and Rick Gates, there was also news of a plea bargain with a heretofore minor figure in the Russia scandal by t...
Updated one month ago