VALRICO -- For now, a principal at one of Hillsborough County's top elementary schools will keep her job.
A school district report released late this afternoon notes the "very stressful work environment" at Alafia Elementary School in Valrico. Focusing more on the school and not so much principal Ellyn Smith, the two-page report cited the school's strengths and weaknesses and suggested recommendations.
The findings were presented to staffers at a meeting after school today. Points in the report include:
- The assessment team found a very stressful work environment for teachers and administrators. In addition, the community is experiencing the stress felt at the school.
- Some parents and staffers fear retaliation for speaking honestly and openly to reviewers sent by the school district.
- Faculty, staff, administration and parents appear fragmented and in distress. One major issue appears to be parents and staff comparing current practices at the school with those of the past.
- Necessary changes cannot be made in isolation by a single person or group. It will take the administration, faculty and staff, as well as the parents, working together to create a healthy school community.
The report also lists a dozen areas in which the school and its staff are doing commendable work.
Superintendent MaryEllen Elia dispatched a team to the A-rated school two weeks ago. The committee spent three days at Alafia and interviewed teachers.
Though previously planned, complaints from parents at a School Board meeting last month helped spark the review. Parents cited high teacher turnover, low morale and student safety issues on campus among their gripes. They asked for Smith to be removed.
Problems between parents and Smith began brewing over the summer. Since June, school officials have held at least six meetings regarding the situation at Alafia, long considered one of the county's best.
Smith has been an educator for more than 30 years. She previously was principal at Seffner Elementary for seven years and has been at Alafia since 2005.
Once she reviews the report, Elia is expected to make a decision regarding Smith's fate.
"These are the recommendations of the team, and ultimately the superintendent decides what happens," district spokesman Steve Hegarty said. "I think she's going to take them very seriously."
Chandra Broadwater, Times staff writer
[Photo: Skip O'Rourke, Times files]
*