LARGO -- Police have arrested two people on charges that they murdered a 4-year-old girl in their custody.
The charges stem from an incident that happened on Aug. 16, but only after the medical examiner ruled the death a homicide and law enforcement located the suspects were they arrested.
Sylvester David Carew, 54, and Nikki Tyler Gardner-Bradley, 38, pictured left, were arrested in Hillsborough County and booked in the Orient Road Jail late Monday.
Police say Carew and Gardner-Bradley brought the child to the emergency room at Northside Hospital in August, although three hospitals were closer to their Largo apartment, Young said. They told staff that the girl was having trouble breathing on the ride to the hospital, though doctors at the hospital said that was unlikely according to Det. Lara Young of the Largo Police Department.
Police believe the likelier story is that the girl was beaten with multiple instruments over a period of time. They say the girl was throwing up and having trouble breathing that day. She was obviously dead when she arrived at the hospital, police say.
"One blow didn’t cause her death," Young said. "It wasn’t necessary to prove who actually swung the implements that struck her. The cause of death was over time while she was in both of their care."
Police had to wait on the official autopsy report that ruled the death a homicide and then a state attorney's review to get arrest warrants on first-degree murder charges for the couple. The autopsy showed the girl, Zineah Taylor Johnson, died of "systematic blunt trauma" and malnutrition was a contributing factor, Young said.
By that time, the pair had moved out of their apartment. Police called on the U.S.
Marshals Florida Regional Fugitive Task Force to find them in
Hillsborough County. They were arrested Monday in the Tampa area.
The girl was Carew's grandchild. Her mother left the girl in her father's care, believing she would be better off with her father and his girlfriend while she tried to become financially stable and take custody. Carew and Gardner-Bradley were on disability and did not work, Young said. They blamed the abuse on each other but did not acknowledge the frequency or severity of abuse that police suspect killed her.
"They both are just so adamant that it was the other, I don’t think we’re getting the real story," Young said.
The girl's mother is not believed to have any other children. Young said she was devastated by the loss and told police that Carew was a good father to her.
--Stephanie Garry, Times Staff Writer