Ashley Tisdale's new nose

This is what High School Musical ice queen Ashley Tisdale looked like in November:

And this is what she looked like this weekend at the Z100 Jingle Ball Christmas concert at Madison Square Garden:

Notice anything different? Or should we say, nose-tice anything different? (Hee hee.) That's right, Sharpay's got a new snout. As previously announced, Tisdale went under the knife recently to repair a deviated septum, giving her a sleeker, more aerodynamic look. (Because, you know, her looks have clearly held her back in life.) Anyway, which Ashley Tisdale do you prefer? Cast your vote in the comments. Here they are once again, side by side:

(Photos: Old nose, Getty Images; new nose, AP)    

Comments

[digital smackdown]

both are ugly

[D'lAiNeE]

I like her old nosse a lot better!:)

[d'lainee]

old nose

[Hellu]

I like her old nose ! :)

[JORDAn]

it's natural beauty if she want's a nose job she should have one, nobody should stop her and complain about it either way shes a babe and i would like to see her in playboy

[abby dowling]

i think her first nose was best because the second nose she looked like a mouse !!!!!!!!!!!!!!no offence but she did

[V]

She did not do this for cosmetic reasons, she did it because she had problems since she was little with her nose being hard to breath in with.

[Dave]

Looked better before, maybe it's the "after" picture but she looks a bit freakish. Almost Michael Jackson midway to phantom of the opera.

Just watch out*

[Dave]

Looked better before, maybe it's the "after" picture but she looks a bit freakish. Almost Michael Jackson midway to phantom of the opera.

Just watch out*

[John P]

She's a total babe either way. Both looks are good enough for me.

[cari]

you know everyone targets the celebratiy's. if i look different one day doesnt mean i got anything new with me.

she was pretty before and after,it is just a bad picture stop tarfgeting them they need a btreak. goshh!

but no she didnt get it,it just looks different because of the shadows and stuff.lay off.

[T]

Hey Dallas - She's 22! This is HER decision!

[Lynn]

It's hard to compare because her hair and makeup are different. I don't really see a difference in the nose itself. Her upper lip seems kind of different. Whatever it's from, I think her before picture is prettier. So does my daughter who is a fan.

[Boca Grande]

The pictures do not give a fair comparison. She is wow! pretty in the first one; blah in the second.

[Richard]

Who really cares? Not me. It's her nose and her life. If she needs surgery to make her feel better, so be it.

[Denise]

These photos are from different angles so really you can't judge if you get 2 photos at least from the same angle I will not be suprised if you find out that there is not that much difference. Also remember it was not done for cosmetic purposes but for her health. I think she is still very pretty.

[Melissa]

I have a severely deviated septum. I've done a lot of research on treatments for it, and it is possible to have surgery to repair a deviated septum and not come out of it with a nose that looks totally different. Hers looks totally different, and it's for the worse. Pretty sad.

[smitty]

i c now...Tisdale reluctantly went under the knife to correct a severely deviated septum.

If it is for a medical reason, it's understood and couldn't be easy for her.

[smitty]

oh why why why would she do that? she was gorgeous beforehand!

[Holly]

First the nose, then it will be something else. It always is! Dumb!!

[Barbara]

When I first looked at the pictures, I thought the first one was the nose job. She looks much better before she did it. I can't imagine why she wanted to change her nose. It changes her entire look and it's not as good.

[TechRider]

Who is she? I guess she looked better in the before, but seriously, who is she?

[john]

Okay you junior genuis' how about finding out about a deviated septum before you open mouth an insert @#$, I mean foot.

[melissa]

What a bunch of hater's!!

[Flann]

I'm undecided as to which nose I'd pick.

[Flann]

I'm undecided as to which nose I'd pick.

[Jon]

Surgery for a deviated septum isn't quite the same thing as for cosmetic purposes.

[Dallas]

When she is a used up rehab junkie like Brit and Lilo it will not matter. Disney wins again. She was cute before. The new pic is terrible. The old snoz gave her extra personality. What the hell is wrong with these kid's parents?

[Jason]

First nose was MUCH better.

[carol]

I noticed the different hair color before I noticed her nose. No big deal...if she can breathe better than the surgery worked. Merry Christmas!

[Verener]

She was cute before and she's still cute. What's the difference.

[Kathy]

Yuck

[Heath]

Well, that was a mistake. Nature's nose was better by far.