I thought I knew the rule ...
but I guess I don't. And I checked Robert's Rules fairly quickly and didn't find anything there. If this rule is there, or someone has an authority on this rule, could you please help me out?
So here it is: Last night I was watching a rerun of High Stakes Poker and it was a hand between Daniel Negreanu, Eli Elezra and Amnon Filippi, pictured at left. Two of those names should be very familiar to you, but the third one might not be. Remember when Ante-Upper John Silva cashed in the WSOP's $1,500 Shootout event? During that tournament John nearly erased Amnon from existence, and I don't mean he knocked him out of the tournament. I mean Amnon was acting, well, like a dork, and John told him so, and then said if Amnon was unhappy that he could take him outside and show him what a dork he was being. (This is a semi-family-friendly blog so I won't type what was actually said.)
So it should come as no surprise to you when I tell you that Amnon was in the middle of this heated pot. At one point Eli mutters something about the pot size, and Amnon chimes in "You can't ask the dealer what the pot size is!" And then Daniel says "Sure he can. It happens all the time, especially in NL," (and I'm paraphrasing this but you get the point). This is when Eli gets mad because some people ask about pot size as a way of slowing the game down, etc. and he didn't want to be called out for that, etc. So there was some tension between Amnon and Eli and Daniel.
Amnon shrunk in his corner for the most part, but he still uttered something like "It's ok if they flatten the pot out for him, but the dealer can't say how much is in there." And then Daniel said the dealer actually could if the player wanted to know. I think they mentioned that you can't do that in tournaments, but I wasn't real sure.
I was always under the impression that the only time you were able to ask the pot amount was when you were playing pot limit, because then it made sense because you had to know what you were betting. But then this came up. And I thought I knew for a FACT that you can't ask pot size in tournaments, as they always preach that this is part of the skill of being a poker player, of knowing how much is in there, etc. So what's the deal? Is there an official rule somewhere? I'd like to know.
-- Chris













