Think tank: Is No Child working? Who knows?
Tampabay.com

Tampa Bay Schools:
Latest poll

Poll: School vouchers
A new report shows that Florida students who use vouchers perform no better than those who don't. Should Florida continue the program?
Yes, the vouchers cost less than public school
No, the vouchers don't lead to better results

Tampa Bay Schools:
Comment Policy

    Please be sure your comments are appropriate before submitting them. Inappropriate comments include content that:
  • Is libelous
  • Is abusive, harassing, or threatening
  • Is obscene, vulgar, or profane
  • Is racially, ethnically or religiously offensive
  • Is illegal or encourages criminal acts
  • Is known to be inaccurate or contains a false attribution
  • Infringes copyrights, trademarks, publicity or any other rights of others
  • Impersonates anyone (actual or fictitious)
  • Solicits funds, goods or services, or advertises
  • The St. Petersburg Times does not edit posts but reserves the right to delete comments that violate our policy.

    Report abuse: abuse@tampabay.com

« Today's news | Main | Their own hurricane »

June 05, 2007

Think tank: Is No Child working? Who knows?

Ed_gl_nclb_logo After an exhaustive look at test data in all 50 states, the Center on Education Policy, a reputable national think tank, concludes in a report released this morning that student achievement in reading and math has improved since No Child Left Behind became the law of the land in 2002, and that far more states have narrowed achievement gaps over that time that widened them. But.

But it's entirely unclear whether No Child deserves the credit, the report says. Part of the reason: No Child-like initiatives were underway in many states (Florida among them) well before President Bush and U.S. Sen. Ted Kennedy (yes, Dems overwhelmingly supported No Child, too, though it might be hard to tell from subsequent media coverage) managed to find a middle ground on education reform. Another reason: It's hard to tell how much the gains are due to kids actually getting smarter versus other considerations. More test prep? Easier tests? Creative number crunching? Could be any or all of those things, too, the CEP report says.

No Child, of course, requires that states annually test students in reading and math, and that they slice and dice the data to see whether poor kids, minority kids, disabled kids and kids who speak English as a second language are also making gains. If the trend lines aren't moving in the right direction for the student population as a whole and for every sub-group, then consequences kick in, including provisions that force school districts to allow children in high-poverty schools to transfer to higher-scoring schools or get private tutoring, free of charge.

The CEP report includes breakdowns state by state, but the Florida section is mostly a rehash of FCAT data going back to 1999. If you're an FCAT data freak (and The Gradebook knows you're out there), then by all means, click here.

Want to know what Education Secretary Spellings thinks about the report? Click here.

Comments

Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

Spellings' statement is the same predictable B.S.

As far "student achievement" is concerned, let's be honest. What we're talking about are test scores. As we've seen with last year's third grade FCAT, simply altering the order of questions can make a huge difference in the outcome of a test. Such tests are easy to manipulate, and the scores can be massaged in different ways.

The main factor here may be the one discussed in Nichols and Berliners' "Collateral Damage: How High-Stakes Testing Corrupts America's Schools."

Nichols and Berliner discuss high-stakes testing in terms of Campbell's Law, which stipulates that "the more any quantitative social indicator is used for social decision-making, the more subject it will be to corruption pressures and the more apt it will be to distort and corrupt the social processes it was intended to monitor."

Nichols and Berliner demonstrate the ubiquity of this law, and firmly establish how its effects have warped the validity of tests as well as the school systems being tested. They demonstrate that the test scores themselves cannot be trusted, let alone secretary Spellings' self-serving pronouncements about them.

Having said that, any rise in test scores since NCLB must be compared to the rise in test scores in years before that. Such comparisons by researcher Gerald Bracey [http://www.statlit.org/Bracey.htm] show that the purported improvement is in the imagination of secretary Spellings.

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Working...
Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been posted. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.

Working...

Post a comment

About This Blog

Get inside the world of Florida education with St. Petersburg Times staff writer Jeffrey S. Solochek and the rest of the Times education reporting team. We'll bring you up-to-date information about the latest education trends, fads and news and dig deep into Tampa Bay area school issues.

E-mail me: solochek@sptimes.com
Join Jeffrey on Facebook
Follow Gradebook news on Twitter

Meet the contributors

Subscribe to this Blog

Add to My Yahoo! Subscribe in NewsGator Online Google Reader or Homepage

Advertisement


The Gradebook Bloggers

Amy Hollyfield covers education issues in the Florida Legislature. E-mail her: ahollyfield@sptimes.com.

Tony Marrero covers Hernando County schools. E-mail him: tmarrero@sptimes.com.

Tom Marshall covers Hillsborough County schools. E-mail him: tmarshall@sptimes.com.

Ron Matus covers state education. E-mail him: matus@sptimes.com.

Jeffrey S. Solochek covers Pasco schools. E-mail him: solochek@sptimes.com.

Thomas C. Tobin covers Pinellas schools. E-mail him: tobin@sptimes.com.

Donna Winchester covers Pinellas County schools. E-mail her: winchester@sptimes.com.

Other education blogs